Tango.info musical work name: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(→alternative titles: missing: criteria of 'really the same') |
m (moved tango.info musical work name to Tango.info musical work name) |
||
(36 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[Category: | [[Category:Tango.info]] | ||
musical work name // musical work title | |||
'''PARTS OF THE PAGE MAY BE OUT OF DATE''' | |||
==Overview== | |||
Until 2012-03-21 the work name field contained alternate names if existent. If A is the main name, and B and C alternative names, then the format was: | |||
A // B // C | |||
== | On 2012-03-21 only the primary name was kept in the main name field and a second field for the alternative names was established. The separator was changed from " // " to " | ". The format now is: | ||
* use | main or primary field : A | ||
secondary field : B | C | |||
The redirects, i.e. entries containing "=>" have been deleted on 2012-03-21. | |||
==Rules== | |||
===Charset=== | |||
* Latin alphabet with diacritics | |||
* Arab numerals | |||
* Special chars: ,.-'?! inversed !? | |||
** TBD: quotation | |||
===Orthography=== | |||
* use correct [[Spanish orthography]] authorised by [[RAE]], with diacritics and correct capitalisation | |||
** Spanish orthography at time of work publication | |||
** or adjust? | |||
===Numbers=== | |||
* two-digit numbers should be written as alphabetic | * two-digit numbers should be written as alphabetic | ||
** 9 de julio -> Nueve de julio | ** 9 de julio -> Nueve de julio | ||
** El 11 -> El once | ** El 11 -> El once | ||
** El 13 -> El trece | ** El 13 -> El trece | ||
*issues | * issues | ||
** three | ** one-digit numbers | ||
*** e.g. Danza húngara n.5 | |||
** three-digit numbers | |||
*** e.g. "Milonga del novecientos" vs "Milonga del 900" | *** e.g. "Milonga del novecientos" vs "Milonga del 900" | ||
** four | ** four-digit numbers | ||
*** e.g. 1910, Cafe 1930 | |||
===Alternative titles=== | |||
If a work has an alternative name, append that with " // ". | |||
The primary title should be | |||
* the title marked with "T" in SADAIC DB or | |||
* the "original title" in ISWC DB | |||
===Other=== | |||
* Anclao en Paris VS Anclado en Paris | |||
* vesre? Tamar(Marta) | |||
==sadaic.org.ar== | ==sadaic.org.ar== | ||
Line 20: | Line 55: | ||
==alternative titles== | ==alternative titles== | ||
*which is primary? Flor de Monserrat vs Pobre negrito | *which is primary? Flor de Monserrat vs Pobre negrito | ||
*current practice varies e.g. second title | *current tango.info practice varies e.g. artist may contain a second title which may or may not be an atlernative. Cases observed include: | ||
**'''true alternative''' - appended in brackets e.g. | **'''true alternative''' - appended in brackets e.g. | ||
**De todo te olvidas (cabeza de novia) | ***De todo te olvidas (cabeza de novia) | ||
***better?: De todo te olvidas (Cabeza de novia) | ****better?: De todo te olvidas (Cabeza de novia) | ||
**'''REDIRECT''' - appended with '=>' e.g. Copa del olvido => La copa del olvido | **'''REDIRECT''' - appended with '=>' e.g. Copa del olvido => La copa del olvido | ||
***only in workslist, indicates a "redirect" i.e. "Copa del olvido" is wrong and the correct title is "La copa del olvido" | ***only in workslist, indicates a "redirect" | ||
****Better?: state only the correct title | ****i.e. "Copa del olvido" is wrong and the correct title is "La copa del olvido" | ||
**'''undetermined''' - appended with ' / ' e.g. | *****Better?: state only the correct title | ||
***Bad: This is indistinguishable from single title containing ' / ' e.g. La Yumba / Adiós Noniño | ****9 de julio => Nueve de julio | ||
**Represented as a distinct work e.g. El tabernero and Tabernero | **'''undetermined''' - appended with ' / ' e.g. | ||
***if | *** Loca de amor / La loca de amor | ||
****missing: criteria of ' | *** Mala estampa / Mala pinta (https://tango.info/T0370086784) | ||
***Bad: This is indistinguishable from single title containing ' / ' e.g. | |||
****La Yumba / Adiós Noniño, a work combining two works. | |||
****Palabras de Carlos Di Sarli / El choclo [https://tango.info/00828767208121-1-1] | |||
**'''Represented as a distinct work''' e.g. El tabernero and Tabernero | |||
***if same work it should be merged and only a redirect left | |||
****missing: criteria of 'same'. | |||
**'''translation''' e.g. | |||
***Sobre las olas (over the waves) |
Latest revision as of 2013-06-09T23:23:36
musical work name // musical work title PARTS OF THE PAGE MAY BE OUT OF DATE
Overview
Until 2012-03-21 the work name field contained alternate names if existent. If A is the main name, and B and C alternative names, then the format was:
A // B // C
On 2012-03-21 only the primary name was kept in the main name field and a second field for the alternative names was established. The separator was changed from " // " to " | ". The format now is:
main or primary field : A secondary field : B | C
The redirects, i.e. entries containing "=>" have been deleted on 2012-03-21.
Rules
Charset
- Latin alphabet with diacritics
- Arab numerals
- Special chars: ,.-'?! inversed !?
- TBD: quotation
Orthography
- use correct Spanish orthography authorised by RAE, with diacritics and correct capitalisation
- Spanish orthography at time of work publication
- or adjust?
Numbers
- two-digit numbers should be written as alphabetic
- 9 de julio -> Nueve de julio
- El 11 -> El once
- El 13 -> El trece
- issues
- one-digit numbers
- e.g. Danza húngara n.5
- three-digit numbers
- e.g. "Milonga del novecientos" vs "Milonga del 900"
- four-digit numbers
- e.g. 1910, Cafe 1930
- one-digit numbers
Alternative titles
If a work has an alternative name, append that with " // ".
The primary title should be
- the title marked with "T" in SADAIC DB or
- the "original title" in ISWC DB
Other
- Anclao en Paris VS Anclado en Paris
- vesre? Tamar(Marta)
sadaic.org.ar
only uses alphabetic work titles
alternative titles
- which is primary? Flor de Monserrat vs Pobre negrito
- current tango.info practice varies e.g. artist may contain a second title which may or may not be an atlernative. Cases observed include:
- true alternative - appended in brackets e.g.
- De todo te olvidas (cabeza de novia)
- better?: De todo te olvidas (Cabeza de novia)
- De todo te olvidas (cabeza de novia)
- REDIRECT - appended with '=>' e.g. Copa del olvido => La copa del olvido
- only in workslist, indicates a "redirect"
- i.e. "Copa del olvido" is wrong and the correct title is "La copa del olvido"
- Better?: state only the correct title
- 9 de julio => Nueve de julio
- i.e. "Copa del olvido" is wrong and the correct title is "La copa del olvido"
- only in workslist, indicates a "redirect"
- undetermined - appended with ' / ' e.g.
- Loca de amor / La loca de amor
- Mala estampa / Mala pinta (https://tango.info/T0370086784)
- Bad: This is indistinguishable from single title containing ' / ' e.g.
- La Yumba / Adiós Noniño, a work combining two works.
- Palabras de Carlos Di Sarli / El choclo [1]
- Represented as a distinct work e.g. El tabernero and Tabernero
- if same work it should be merged and only a redirect left
- missing: criteria of 'same'.
- if same work it should be merged and only a redirect left
- translation e.g.
- Sobre las olas (over the waves)
- true alternative - appended in brackets e.g.